STORY ARCHIVE
Chiropractors
Are chiropractors putting babies at risk? A special report into the ambitions of the chiropractic industry.
TRANSCRIPT&
download segment
(average size 10 MB)
NARRATIONChiropractic therapy is a modern reinvention of the ancient art of spinal manipulation. In recent times, this practice has become steeped in controversy.Emeritus Professor John DwyerMuch of modern chiropractic, unfortunately, has descended into the realm of quackery.NARRATIONUniversities are being accused of teaching pseudoscience.Dr Michael VaggIt would be misleading to present that to students.Dr Aidan McGuiganThe results are really speaking for themselves. It comes down to 'the proof is in the pudding'.BelindaWe've been coming for asthma.KirbieA little bit of colic and reflux.NARRATIONThis has the medical fraternity up in arms.Dr Steve HambletonWell, this is a great concern of the medical profession, that there are some individuals taking their infants and young children to chiropractors.NARRATIONIt's even created factions within the chiropractic industry.Dr John ReggarsI am angered and I am embarrassed for the profession.NARRATIONWill chiropractors become the new family doctor, and are they putting our children at risk?Dr Maryanne DemasiNow, most people go to the chiropractor for back pain, and, despite its surging popularity, its proven benefit is fairly limited. A review of spinal manipulation showed that it could alleviate lower back pain, but it was no more effective than heat therapy, or even a good massage.NARRATIONChiropractors have an important role in healthcare when it comes to treating musculoskeletal problems. But a new trend is emerging.Emeritus Professor John DwyerIt's the move into paediatrics, and the enormous number of chiropractors who are trying to set up paediatric clinics and claiming that they can cure a range of paediatric conditions, that is really troublesome.NARRATIONThere have been reports that chiropractors are the new refuge for a range of health problems, like asthma, colic, reflux and autism.BelindaLast week, Jade had an asthma attack and I rang quickly, and said, 'Can you fit her in?' And they said yes straightaway. We put her in and it stopped, completely stopped.Dr Maryanne DemasiWow.BelindaShe was really... (Gasps wheezily) ..you know, the full-on wheezing.Dr Maryanne DemasiSo, if your girls get sick, do you take them to the GP or the chiropractor first?HeleneMy first point of call is always the chiropractor. I didn't like to put drugs into their body if it wasn't necessary. So, that's what I found with a GP, that they were very quick to just - quick - write a script and off they go. I didn't feel as if there was a lot of caring, or individual care at least, with the children.NARRATIONWhere babies used to be rare patients, they're now common in a number of clinics. Newborns and toddlers make up over a third of this chiropractor's client base.Man..areas of subluxation that I can feel there that are immediately improved after you adjust it like that.KirbieI would definitely send her along to the chiropractor first to see that we couldn't settle her first. I think... her being a newborn, I think a nice way to approach it is to go as natural as possible, and to give them care that's gentle and... you know. I think that's more important than sending them along to a GP.Dr Maryanne DemasiWere you surprised that they could treat a whole range of medical conditions?BelindaYeah, I've been very surprised, because I wasn't... I wasn't really expecting the answer to be yes to be able to sort out asthma.Dr Aidan McGuiganI've witnessed myself and read reports of improvements in colic, bed wetting, asthma. There's a lot of word-of-mouth information that is going around the public that someone's child has been helped in that way. So they've come to the chiropractor.Dr Maryanne DemasiNow, you may be wondering how adjusting the spine could possibly help conditions that have nothing to do with the spine. Well, perhaps a brief history lesson may help explain where this came from.NARRATIONChiropractic therapy was founded in 1895 by an American magnetic healer called 'DD Palmer'. In his building worked a janitor who complained he was hard of hearing. DD Palmer decided to perform an adjustment on the man's spine, and, in a miraculous feat, claimed to have cured him of profound deafness. Palmer hypothesised that aligning the spine unblocked nerve flow through the body and restored the man's hearing. From this, he proposed that a misaligned spine was the cause of virtually all human ailments.Dr Maryanne DemasiFast forward to today, and the Chiropractic Association still believes that curing deafness with spinal manipulation is plausible.Dr Tony CrokeWell, it makes sense that... that fellow lifted something he held, heard a pop in his back and then he became deaf, and, 17 years later, DD did something and his hearing came back. It would suggest that there was a relationship there.Dr Maryanne DemasiBetween hearing and the spinal column?Dr Tony CrokeYeah. Yeah. And there are neural pathways that run from where he was supposed to have been adjusted, up into the brain stem, that can impact on function.NARRATIONJohn Cunningham, a spinal expert, disagrees.Mr John CunninghamThere's no nerves that control hearing that have anything to do with the neck. They all come from the base of the skull, which simply cannot be influenced by any sort of spinal manipulation. I would have concern over someone's appreciation of anatomy if they were to claim that the middle ear and Eustachian tube is affected in any way by a nerve that comes from the spine.NARRATIONTony Croke explains that even the slightest misalignment in the spine can act like a traffic jam in the central nervous system, and lead to disease. In chiropractic circles, it's called a 'subluxation'.Dr Tony CrokeAnd so it's not necessarily that you have to compress the nerve root on the way out, but, in fact, the messages coming back in can be distorted because of that static in the nervous system travelling back upward.Mr John Cunningham(Laughs) I'm sorry. It's just senseless rubbish. Um... If there is a static, well, why haven't they shown it? If that is the mechanism, they've had all these years to describe it, to... document it, to study it, to perform experiments on it. Why haven't they?NARRATIONDr Michael Vaggr is a pain specialist, and disagrees with the chiropractic theory about traffic jams in the central nervous system. During surgery, he deliberately scrambles the nerve signals to the spine, so that patients can get pain relief.Dr Michael VaggWe use spinal cord neuromodulators to electrically scramble the information that's going up and down the rear part of the spinal cord. And we see no evidence that that produces anything other than pain relief in most of our patients. So, I think, those observations are not consistent with the chiropractic view that optimum health depends on there being absolutely no interference with nerve function at all.NARRATIONPaediatrician Michael Fahey says the science doesn't stack up.Dr Michael FaheyThe idea that there are energy flows up and down the spine that cause disease in organs doesn't fit with our current understanding of science. There's been a number of systematic reviews which examined chiropractic use for things like asthma, colic, bed wetting, ear infections, and don't show that there's any evidence that chiropractic is effective. If we look at the asthma trial, there's only been one done which has been conducted in a rigorous way, and they compared chiropractic therapy to a sham therapy. There was no change when they looked at the outcomes of respiratory function tests, the objective measures.ManThat's it, let's get to the air flow.NARRATIONExperts say quality of research is lacking. Even though patients swear by it, therapies need to be tested in rigorous trials to remove bias and the placebo effect.Dr Maryanne DemasiDo you think it could be placebo?Dr Tony CrokeI bring focus to the fact that I want them to feel... safe, and that one of the knock-on consequences of that, just as a side benefit, is that there may be a better placebo effect - that they might feel more confident and they might have a better outcome just because of that. I'm OK with that.Dr John ReggarsChiropractors have relied on anecdotal evidence, and, I think, because of their fervent belief in what they do, that they disregard or put aside the scientific evidence, which shows that it's either ineffective or inconclusive.NARRATIONJohn Reggars, a chiropractor, says he only treats musculoskeletal problems, and that adjusting newborns is ridiculous.Dr John ReggarsNow you've got an infant. OK. The nervous system is not developed, its bony structure isn't fully developed. So I fail to see how anyone could find a problem with a one-week-old baby by touching their spine, and therefore...NARRATIONHe says many paediatric conditions resolve spontaneously, like ear infections.Dr John ReggarsWe know, from all the literature, that 80 per cent of those children will be better within five to seven days without any treatment. So, if you take your baby to a chiropractor with a middle ear infection, he treats the baby, the baby gets better. Well, he's taking credit for it, and you also think that he's performed a miracle.Dr Maryanne DemasiWhat concerns you the most about chiropractors treating very young babies?Dr John ReggarsI don't think the general chiropractor is trained well enough to actually diagnose problems with infants.NARRATIONAnd herein lies the irony. The Chiropractic Association has announced a bold ambition to become the new family doctor.Dr Maryanne DemasiSo chiropractors really want to be the doctors of first choice?Dr Tony CrokeIt's a great idea.Dr Maryanne DemasiAre chiropractors qualified to handle a whole range of medical complaints?Dr Tony CrokeWe're five years university trained, and that gives us the capacity to assess and then redirect. So, of course, if you need your tonsils taken out, I'm not your guy. If you need brain surgery, somebody else needs to help you with that. My job is to find and assess whether you need to be just with me, whether you need to be co-managed, or whether you need to be referred completely.NARRATIONNot surprisingly, this aspiration has outraged the Medical Association.Dr Steve HambletonYour first point of care in the Australia health system needs to be your family doctor, a medically-trained person, who's comprehensively trained from cradle to grave to look at you and your family and the environment.Dr Maryanne DemasiIs this a bad reflection on medicine that more and more people are turning to alternatives?Emeritus Professor John DwyerI think it is. Dissatisfaction with a quickie turnover turnstile medicine approach is a factor that drives people into the misguided hands of people who are doing the patient no good at all.Dr Michael VaggThere is a lot wrong with mainstream medicine, but just because some planes crash doesn't mean we should start using flying carpets. So you have to have a plausible alternative if there is a problem.NARRATIONWhat's most disturbing about chiropractors being the first port of call in the health system is that many don't support vaccination, which is the most basic form of public healthcare. Chiropractors are the largest number of professionals that support one of Australia's most misleading anti-vaccination lobbies, of which Tony was a member.Dr Tony CrokeI have been in the past, yeah. I'm not now. My reason for being involved was to access the data and have a look.Dr Maryanne DemasiSo what's your view after you've viewed the data?Dr Tony CrokeMy view is the same as the Chiropractors' Association, that is that it's not what I do. People need to make an informed choice and need to chat to their GP about it.Dr Maryanne DemasiAre you personally for or against vaccination?Dr Aidan McGuiganI prefer not to. My own research and my own choices have been made, and that's personal to me. The Chiropractic Association does not deal with vaccinations. We're neutral.Dr Steve HambletonNeutral is not good enough. If the Chiropractic Association takes some time, reads the evidence, they should conclude just like everyone else that there's a major benefit.Emeritus Professor John DwyerIn this day and age, that is completely reprehensible. Vaccination is probably the most successful intervention is medicine, period, and not to have a position is intolerable.NARRATIONIn 2010, Sydney chiropractor Nimrod Weiner was reported for making false claims, and inciting fear about vaccination. John Cunningham lodged a formal complaint to the Chiropractic Board.Mr John CunninghamNimrod Weiner's website, I was concerned had information on it that didn't represent the best available evidence with regards to immunisation. For example, one of the claims that he made was that vaccination actually causes Sudden Infant Death Syndrome, whereas the larger studies that are being done show that vaccination actually halves your risk of Sudden Infant Death Syndrome. He also claimed that vaccination causes autism, when, in actual fact, a large Danish study of over half a million children has proven, without any shadow of a doubt, that there is absolutely no link between vaccination and autism.NARRATIONNimrod Weiner declined to comment. The Federal Government appoints a regulatory board to preside over chiropractors. They enforce codes of conduct and ensure public safety. But the integrity of this regulator has been questioned over their failure to encourage that chiropractors support vaccination.Dr Phillip DonatoWe're not here to promote clinical guidelines, all those sort of clinical areas.Dr Maryanne DemasiBut you're supposed to be protecting the public.Dr Phillip DonatoWe are and where that has come to our attention as a notification, we've dealt with it satisfactorily.NARRATIONBut it seems in vain. This waiting room is full of misleading information. Here, a booklet by AVN, a widely discredited anti-vaccination group. This book suggests that parents delay their child's vaccination program, and even recommends using scientifically unproven homeopathic vaccines as an alternative. Patients are enticed by celebrity endorsements and unscientific remedies. Websites are riddled with false information that chiropractic can help with conditions like autism, ADHD, even HIV. This from a profession that claims to be science-based, and yet it all appears to slip past the regulator.Dr Phillip DonatoWell, I don't know. We haven't been made aware that that's still the case. We don't actually go out and look for it. The onus is on the public and members of the community to bring it to our attention.Dr Maryanne DemasiHow is the public meant to know whether or not the information they're receiving is correct to bring it to the Board in the first place?Dr Phillip DonatoI don't particularly have the answers for that. We're very conscious of not over-regulating - but, at the same time, not under-regulating. We're trying to always maintain a right touch, or a proportionate... what we call a proportional approach. Um... But it is difficult. That's certainly a challenge, and I take your point.NARRATIONBut when it comes to coughing up money, it's the taxpayer that loses. Last year, the government spent over ten million dollars on Medicare rebates for chiropractic services. A quarter of that was for paediatrics. Professor John Dwyer says it's abusing the public purse.Emeritus Professor John DwyerYes, absolutely, and that's why we wrote to the Health Minister, asking her to have the chief medical officers review of what practices the government puts money into, and the answer was, 'No, we won't do that for chiropractic, 'cause we've got a national registration board, which is going to protect the consumers.' Palpably, it's not. Look at the chiropractic websites and you'll see just how determined and how penetrative this nonsense is.NARRATIONThis Sydney-based chiropractor claims to correct the length of a child's leg with a clicking device called an activator.ManFirst we adjust this. No complaints there, and you get an instant lengthening. See?Emeritus Professor John DwyerI mean, what can you ask more? Just a few clicks and the child's chronic problem is fixed.Dr Maryanne DemasiSo, how unscientific is that?Emeritus Professor John DwyerWell, it's totally unscientific. Obviously when you're positioning a child on a bench like that, you could do anything with your legs, and then he moves the legs until they're equal, and the random clicking away, from the buttocks to the upper spine, with the instant results, this is what is so objectionable.ManThere is a muscle spasm around the vertebra...Emeritus Professor John DwyerIt was interesting, that the adjustor is then used on the neck, where there are no anatomical structures that, if you altered them in any way, would fix leg shortening.ManGood, she's done. Easy. Here she comes.Emeritus Professor John DwyerIf he does really believe that he's just cured a musculoskeletal problem that child had - a shortened leg - then that is really sad. That's really dangerous, because, as Chekhov said, the quacks that the most dangerous are the ones that really believe it.NARRATIONThere was a review of eight trials involving the activator which showed it had benefit. But that paper also concluded that all the studies had poor design, small sample sizes and no control groups.Dr Maryanne DemasiNow, you could argue that if parents want to spend their money on therapies that don't work, then that's their choice. But what if that therapy was causing harm?Dr Tony CrokeThere was a study published in 2011 which couldn't find a single significant adverse event in the care of children by chiropractors. Somewhere in the world, in the last 20-plus years, someone would've said something that would've ended up in the medical literature. At least somebody somewhere. But to have a zero result, that's pretty decent.Dr Michael VaggI think Tony could've looked a little harder in the literature - because, without a lot of difficulty, I found a paper from 2007 in a very widely-known journal called Pediatrics, which documented some very serious adverse events, including two fatalities and including 20 delayed diagnoses of serious conditions like cancer and scoliosis, etc, where those people had been managed by chiropractors. So, that's just one study. When one looks through the literature, you do find these things if you look hard enough.NARRATIONThe problem is, chiropractors don't have a formal system in place for recording adverse events. The regulator can see it's not ideal.Dr Phillip DonatoWhat currently exists is really a lack of hardcore data in terms of, you know, is it or isn't it.Dr Maryanne DemasiWell, why not establish a register to record adverse events?Dr Phillip DonatoLook, great idea, and I think that's something that was presented to the profession last year here, and there are certainly moves afoot now to sort of say, 'How do we do this and how do we set it up?' And that's important to know, and it's a responsible thing to do for a profession.Dr Maryanne DemasiThe safety of manipulating a baby's spine has recently been brought into question. A three-month-old baby was rushed here to Monash Medical Centre after allegedly having its neck broken from chiropractic therapy. Dr Fahey has confirmed this on X-ray, but says further details of the case cannot be disclosed due to ongoing legal action.NARRATIONAnd it's not just the risk to babies.Lucie SnapeWhen I got there, he sort of said, 'Well, what's wrong with you?' and I said, 'Nothing.' 'I'm just here for a tune-up,' I think, was the words that I used. And, in hindsight, really, he should probably at that point have said, 'Well, if there's nothing wrong with you, there's no reason for you to actually be here.'Dr Maryanne DemasiYet he continued to perform a manipulation on you.Lucie SnapeYeah. On my back and my neck, yeah. There was no reason. There was nothing wrong with my neck. There was no pain in my neck. He then held my head with his two hands, and lifted my head... You know, it felt like he was lifting my head up. And tilted my chin and then cracked that way and then cracked that way.NARRATIONUnfortunately, this was the result. Lucie's vertebral artery, that runs down the side of her neck, has been dissected. These neck manipulations are known to be risky.Dr Maryanne DemasiGee, that's confronting to watch, isn't it?Dr Michael VaggMm. It's the force of the thrust that is the thing that's believed to cause injuries.Lucie SnapeI literally couldn't move my neck to the left or the right. It was stuck, yeah, and I was crying, I was incredibly distressed.NARRATIONLucie was very fortunate she didn't have a stroke. But there was no way she was prepared for what lay ahead.Lucie SnapeThat sort of was the beginning of what's been now three years of pain management, treatments, diagnosis, testing, a lot of money, a lot of time, a lot of emotional energy. You know, it's been a very difficult journey.NARRATIONLucie did sue for damages, but the legal bills became insurmountable, so she withdrew her case. Professor Dwyer, who co-founded Friends of Science in Medicine, says he wants universities to stop teaching chiropractic therapy.Emeritus Professor John DwyerI don't believe that there is sufficient science to warrant university education. I think they should get out of the chiropractic business. There simply isn't enough fundamental science in chiropractic to warrant a five-year course. And, I think, the universities, by supplying these courses, give credibility. Those people would be much better off spending their time enrolling in a physiotherapy course and learning a whole lot of practical evidence-based skills. There's no place for chiropractic in a really strong, academically-based university.NARRATIONProfessor Peter Coloe is the Pro Vice-Chancellor at RMIT, where they teach chiropractic. He rejects the criticism.Professor Peter ColoeWe have a focus on strong evidence-based criteria, basic sciences, and we don't teach pseudoscience.NARRATIONRMIT supplied me with lecture notes from the course, and I had Dr Vagg look over them.Dr Michael VaggThere is inaccurate material that's been presented alongside material that's completely wrong, alongside material that's completely speculative, alongside some very sound anatomy. So, if you're a student, and you don't have the training, or the background or the experience to tell what's what, then that, I think, is gravely concerning. Part of the responsibility of the university is to be a custodian of knowledge, and a dispenser and a trainer of that knowledge. It's not to try and put things over the students in a way that leads them to come out of uni and then find out that they've been misled, or that things have been misrepresented to them.Professor Peter ColoeIf that information can be documented, I'll take it back to the school and get them to look at it.NARRATIONBut what hope is there when a staff member actually believes the pseudoscience? We found a casual employee of RMIT making unsubstantiated claims on her website about autism.Dr Maryanne DemasiNow, there's no evidence in the literature that chiropractic therapy can help with autism.Professor Peter ColoeAgreed.Dr Maryanne DemasiAre you not concerned that she may impart this pseudoscientific knowledge onto the students? They're very impressionable.Professor Peter ColoeStudents are impressionable, yes. If we bring external experts in, that they would come in to teach a particular area, we're not bringing someone in to teach things like the effect of chiropractic on autism.Dr Maryanne DemasiIt's a bad reflection on the university that RMIT graduates are going out there and practising non-evidence-based techniques.Professor Peter ColoeWell, our graduates, we don't control them once they go out.NARRATIONWhen we approached Dr Willis for comment, she deferred us to RMIT. The university did approach her, and she has since removed the claim from her website. In a surprise move, but one that is applauded by the medical profession, Sydney's Macquarie University has recently announced their plans to scrap its chiropractic course in a bid to remain focused on science.Dr Maryanne DemasiMeanwhile, the conflict within the chiropractic union is palpable. But John Reggars still believes he can champion change so that opposing sides of the profession can move into alignment.Dr John ReggarsWe still have an opportunity to become spine specialists, non-surgical spine specialists. We have the skills and we have the training, and if we funnel our energies in towards that aim and that goal, and disregard the extraneous things that are going on within the profession, then we will prosper.
Reporter: Dr Maryanne Demasi
Producer: Dr Maryanne Demasi
Researcher: Dr Maryanne Demasi
Camera: Ron Ekkel Kevin MayMick FanningMark Farnell
Sound: Paul FreemanStephen Ravich Paul CastellaroGavin MarshGraeme Cornish
Editor: Vaughan Smith
Story Contacts
Emeritus Professor John Dwyer
Immunologist, University of NSW
Dr Tony Croke (Chiro)
Chiropractic Association of Australia
Dr Michael Vagg
Rehab Physician, Geelong Hospital
Dr Michael Fahey
Paediatric Neurologist, Monash Medical Centre
Dr Aidan McGuigan (Chiro)
Chiropractor
Dr Steve Hambleton
President, Australian Medical Association
Dr Phillip Donato (Chiro)
Chair, Chiropractic Board of Australia
Mr John Cunningham
Spinal Surgeon, Epworth Hospital
Dr John Reggars (Chiro) OAM
Chiropractor
Prof Peter Coloe
Pro Vice Chancellor, RMIT
Related Info
Mylene Goodwin
Moderator: Dr Demasi has no affiliations with the FSM executive.
Nusia Warren
Nick Hodgson
ABC (Moderator) -
Gary Roberts
ABC (Moderator) -
Graydon harris
Jay Russian.
Jake Joyce
ABC (Moderator) -
Dr Tom Potisk
Nick Hodgson
Moderator: Dr Demasi is neither a member nor a supporter of the FOS.
Chris DeVoy
David Bates
Julie - 19 July, 2013
Skylar Gemmer
Gemma Dennett
David Brookman
Charles Blum
Charles Blum
Nick Hodgson
ANON PHYSIO
Charles Blum
Nick Hodgson
Look up and live
Nick Hodgson
Frances Robb
David Brookman
Jay Russian.
Catalyst moderator
Ben Heslop
Samantha Mckay
Rebecca Harwin
Rebecca Harwin
Rebecca Harwin
Nick Hodgson
Nick Hodgson
Charles Blum
Daniel Franklin
John Cunningham
Nick Hodgson
Michael Meacham
Julia Hilton
John Cunningham
Auden Audrey
science means not being fooled
Nick Hodgson
Gary Little
Megan Bartley
Maureen O'Driscoll
Nick Hodgson
Nick Hodgson
Rational-Man
Nick Hodgson
vicki ryan
Frances L. Wellington
Dan Germouse
Sonja Hardy
Gilles Lamarche DC
Paul Willis
Frank Collins
No Time Like The Future
Frank Collins
David Driscoll
Richard Green
John Cunningham
truebeliever64
L Thornton
John Cunningham
Frank Collins
Nick Allan
No Time Like The Future
Tony Croke
Richard Green
Meghan Stevens
Frank Collins
Sonja Hardy
Graham Taylor
Frank Collins
Peter O'Dwyer
Richard Green
John Cunningham
Robynne Hartshorne
Brent Kvam
Frank Collins
Lorna Hodgson
Justin Carslake
Frank Collins
Richard Green
Justin Carslake
Kaye Payne
Frank Collins
marlene bracks
Rachel Versteegen
Jodie Hughes
No Time Like The Future
Peter Bryner
Doug Bright
Jeff Jefferson
Diedre Jones
Maree Darby
Daniel Kostur
john o'reilly
Meghan Stevens
Sonja Hardy
john o'reilly
Anthony Lee
Still Laughing
vicki ryan
Chiropractors
In response
No Time Like The Future
Dr William Moore
Sonja Hardy
Lily Agarwal
Sonja Hardy
Sonja Hardy
Bill Statham
Rachel Versteegen
Susi Tuita
Jason Lemon
No Time Like The Future
Brigitte Bennett
David Driscoll
David Driscoll
David M Driscoll
David Driscoll
No Time Like The Future
David M Driscoll
Rod O'Connor
Low Carb Diet: Fat or Fiction
Recent research suggests low carb diets could improve the lives of people suffering from obesity and diabetes.